Courts across the country disagree about whether event contracts are federally regulated derivatives or a form of gambling subject to state or Tribal law. Event contracts are derivatives that pay out based on whether a specified event occurs, such as whether a hurricane makes landfall or the GDP exceeds a specified rate. They trade on designated contract markets, exchanges regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”). The dispute has produced litigation nationwide, and federal courts have reached conflicting decisions, meaning the issue is likely to be taken up by the Supreme Court. How event contracts are characterized will determine whether, and how, Americans can access these markets.

Several states argue that an event contract is a wager subject to state gaming law, and they have gone to court to stop exchanges from listing these products. The states’ theory would reach far beyond event contracts: the same reasoning would let any state treat a derivative as gambling based on what it references, putting derivatives on crops, energy, interest rates, and currencies within reach of state gaming law. That result would unravel the uniform federal framework Congress built when it placed derivatives markets under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction.

The division between federally regulated derivatives and state-regulated gambling products is more than a century old. In the 1880s, several states passed laws treating futures contracts as gambling, and courts reviewed contracts one at a time, so traders could not know in advance whether their contracts would be legally enforceable. When Congress debated federal futures legislation in 1921, the bill’s sponsor warned that under one such state law, a grain dealer "would not know, until there was a construction of that law by some court, as to whether he was an outlaw or not." In the laws that Congress passed in 1921 and 1922, it distinguished a bucket shop, an operation where "the owner assumes the risk of the trades, like the keeper of a gambling house," from a federally designated contract market. Congress has preserved that division ever since.

On October 19, the CFTC published two companion releases that codify the century-old division between derivatives and wagers into formal rulemaking. The first, an interim final rule that took effect the same day, excludes from the definition of "swap," one of the main categories of derivatives the CFTC regulates, the wagers and casino games that state- or Tribe-licensed operators offer outside any exchange or other multilateral market. The second, a proposed rule, would include in that definition the event contracts that registered exchanges now offer. Both releases confirm existing practice: the states have long regulated gambling activities, and the CFTC has overseen event contract markets since the early 1990s.

Today, HPC filed comment letters supporting both releases. Our comments explain that the two rules draw an objective line between the markets the Commission regulates and the wagers the states and tribes regulate, based on who offers a product and the risks inherent in how market participants access it. We urge the Commission to adopt the interim final rule as final with the rule text unchanged and to adopt the proposed rule with one addition.

Our comments reflect the key principle that products offering similar economic exposure are often properly regulated under different regimes. For example, a homeowner or investor can take exposure to the price of heating oil by buying oil today, fixing a price with a local distributor, trading futures, entering into a swap with a dealer, or buying a distributor's shares, and each of these transactions falls under a different set of rules. The CFTC and the Securities and Exchange Commission confirmed that principle in the derivatives context in 2012, when they excluded insurance products and ordinary consumer agreements from the definition of "swap," despite their economic similarities to some instruments that were regulated as swaps. Each instrument presents different risks to the people who use it, and the regulatory framework governing a given instrument depends on its unique risks, not its economics.

A wager and an event contract are different products with different risks, even when they pay out based on the same event. A wager is placed against the house, which sets the price, takes the other side of each transaction, and profits when its customers lose. The bet stays between the customer and the house until the event is over. An event contract on a designated contract market is priced by competing bids and offers on a central order book, and the exchange is neutral and earns a transaction fee however the contract settles. The trade is cleared through a registered clearinghouse, and the holder can sell or close the position at any time before the event. The CFTC’s releases distinguish between the two based on those important structural differences.

Our comments ask the Commission to take six steps:

  1. Adopt the interim final rule as a final rule with the rule text unchanged, and reaffirm the Commission’s finding of good cause to adopt the rule before taking public comment.
  2. Confirm that "applicable State or Tribal law" means the law of the state or Tribe that licensed the operator, rather than the most restrictive gaming law in the country.
  3. Confirm that a state's label cannot bring a contract traded on a CFTC-registered market within the exclusion, and that the exclusion gives states no basis to regulate privately negotiated (over-the-counter) swaps that reference events.
  4. Add to the preamble a short, nonexclusive list of the hallmarks of a gambling product, such as whether the operator takes the other side of every transaction, to help classify new products.
  5. Add a cross-reference to the gambling exclusion in the proposed rule's text, so that the two provisions read as a single, two-sided rule.
  6. Define "event contract" using the Commodity Exchange Act’s language, as a contract whose payment depends on an occurrence or contingency other than a change in the price of a commodity.

The two rules would give participants in event contract markets certainty grounded in regulation, applied uniformly across the country. A stable federal boundary for derivatives is part of a clear, regulated path for Americans to access onchain markets, and we will continue engaging with the Commission and staff as both rules move forward.

Read our full comment letters on the interim final rule and the proposed rule.